Detailed monetary data for China continue to look more positive. Three trends stand out: a further slowing of the flow of household money into time deposits; a resumption of capital inflows; and continuation of the faster pace of PBC lending to the financial sector.

Detailed Q3 data include a few puzzles: net export contribution stable when the trade surplus declined; construction dropping sharply when property has looked less bad; and quarterly investment growing when monthly FAI has dropped. The one detail that really adds up: manufacturing remaining strong.

Property is weak, manufacturing FAI has slowed, consumer spending on goods is soft, and price deflation isn't lifting. However, services consumption is better, and output of both goods and services is growing by more than 5%. The government likely still thinks the economy is muddling through.

Yesterday's monetary and credit data for September weren't bullish, but I do think they were incrementally encouraging: excluding CGBs, credit issuance and the credit impulse ticked up; the firming of M1 growth has continued; and there is more evidence of a floor in the M1:M2 ratio.

For the first time since 2021, my models show a fall in the probability of easing. The backdrop is effective monetary policy: inflation is low, but there aren't signs of rising real rates. For now, my base case is rates stop falling. For rates to rise, inflation needs to show up outside of equities.

The stabilisation of PPI is fragile, with continued sharp falls in some of the sectors targeted by anti-involution, as well as continued weakness in building materials prices. In CPI, falling food prices will eventually reverse, but soft services prices shows underlying CPI inflation remains weak.

Shipments to the US remain as low as in May. But with exports to other regions continuing to rise, the uptrend in overall shipments that began in mid-2023 remains intact. At the same time, imports in the last few months have risen a bit, so the trade surplus, finally, has eased back.

Upstream prices in level terms have stabilised, but as with food prices, are still falling YoY. With aggregate spending and PMI output prices remaining weak, core inflation is unlikely to be rising. The one upside risk is an end to the multi-year trend of households shifting money to time deposits.

This discrepancy in the PMIs – S&P versions better, official PMIs still weak – is puzzling. Probably, the overall message is that China is back to a period of muddling through, with the cycle not robust, but getting some support from the better equity market and rise in the credit impulse.