The platform for tracking and understanding East Asia macro
Equities say that data are now dated, with PBC policy meaning a decent recovery is in the works. But in assessing whether that's right, the data are important, showing how much work policy needs to do. The PMIs were weaker again in September, with the construction PMI, especially, rarely worse.
A summary of what happened on East Asia Econ last week, and what to look for in the next seven days.
I've already posed the question of why the PBC only cut 20 bp. Today, I've got a follow-up: why wasn't fiscal announced at the same time? Reports suggest that is in the works, but China is best-placed of anywhere to do coordinated monetary-fiscal. It feels significant that this didn't happen.
Today's survey from the BOK doesn't show much change in business sentiment, which remains weak. But it does point to a real softening in pricing in manufacturing. With the domestic macro data now largely in place for a cut, the remaining issues for the BOK are housing, and external developments.
If the US-led global trend is a sort of reversion to mean, then Asia has two very differentiated dynamics. On the one hand, there's Japan and Taiwan, which look like breaking structurally to the upside. On the other, there's China, which is more sluggish than at any time in the last 30 years.
This to me is the interesting question about yesterday: given weak prices, and now CNY appreciation, why wasn't the rate cut bigger?
Confidence and overall inflation expectations fell in September's consumer confidence survey. But property price expectations ticked up. The change wasn't big, but is enough to cloud the outlook for a BOK that in recent months has explicitly associated its monetary stance with the property market.
The BOJ's stance now has two clear dimensions. One, as before, is its constructive view of the domestic economy. But now there's also an explicit concern about US growth. As long as one offsets the other, the BOJ has time. However, if the US soft lands, then the BOJ will have ground to make up.
A summary of what happened on East Asia Econ last week, and what to look for in the next seven days.
So, no surprise from the BOJ today. But the bank's statement remained constructive, revising up consumption. Today's separate services inflation data for August was also firm. Import prices have receded on the rising JPY, but we'd think the BOJ should be hiking again with a strong Q3 Tankan.
Taiwan's CBC kept rates on hold yesterday, but hiked the RRR to control housing. More interesting was the bank's very benign outlook: growth neither fast nor slow, and inflation falling to just within its target range. Particularly regarding inflation, that doesn't allow much room for error.
China's imports are two-speed. That's like the economy, but with a big difference: whereas for macro it is property that is weak while mfg is strong, for imports it is commodities that are more resilient than capital goods. Like the overall macro muddle through, that resilience likely can't last.
A summary of what happened on East Asia Econ last week, and what to look for in the next seven days.
August data suggest GDP is now only growing by around 4% YoY. The headwinds remain property activity, which dropped again in August to new lows, and retail sales, which has now contracted MoM in five of the first eight months of 2024. Sustaining muddle through is getting much more difficult.
Today's industrial price data for the first 10 days of September and property prices for August show intensified deflationary pressure. Yesterday's monetary data were weak. The PBC said yesterday that it will focus on price stability, but it also said it has plenty of other things to do as well.
More than 12M ago, we argued yields should fall. In that respect, today's drop to record lows isn't a surprise. We don't see anything fundamental yet to cause a change in direction. That's based on four factors: the PBC's reaction function, inflation, household savings, and the CNY.
It is clear that the market moves that accompanied the BOJ's July policy changes are impacting prices. But it isn't obvious that they have derailed the underlying path for the economy. It seems to us the door remains open for an October hike, with the obvious risk being events in the US.
Data today show exports still growing, and UE still low. The BOK hasn't been ignoring exports, but the bank has been more focused on weak domestic demand. The labour market data don't suggest that weakness is disappearing, with strength in employment concentrated in state and part-time positions.
It seems increasingly unlikely that exports can offset the weakness of domestic demand. Today's export data for August weren't strong. Volumes might be better, but the regional export cycle is likely peaking, and that at a time when China's domestic demand seems to be weakening further.
While exports jumped in August, with signs that the semi upswing is losing steam, it still seems likely that the export peak is near. Pretty much all the growth is coming from the US, which is propelling a surge in the bilateral trade surplus. That makes Taiwan vulnerable if Trump wins re-election.
The Economy Watchers survey improved in August. That matters, as if the market vol around the BOJ meeting in July had caused damage to the cycle, it should be showing up by now. The rise in the household score is particularly important, given the previous weakness of consumption.
MoM core CPI fell again in August, and while perhaps a bit too early to pronounce that China is definitively in core deflation, it is getting close. PPI deflation also worsened, and the leads suggest that will continue. Despite stronger food prices, it is likely interest rates continue to fall.
Last week I gave a short conference presentation updating the framework I've been using to think about China today versus Japan in the 1990s. The slides focus on deflation, manufacturing, currencies, and household consumption.
A summary of what happened on East Asia Econ last week, and what to look for in the next seven days.
Rather than thinking a weaker USD will be a catalyst for a stronger Chinese cycle, we worry more that a stronger CNY means even more downside risk, being another reason to conclude that the muddle through of the last 18M is running out of road.